Fire Your Inner Troll: Why Shame Never Works

Ever caught yourself thinking that your inner critic is actually helping you? I used to believe that too. But here’s the truth: that voice isn’t a coach, it’s a troll, and shame has never been an effective long-term motivator. In this episode, I share the science behind why shame doesn’t work, how it messes with your brain, and the practical strategies you can use to coach yourself with compassion instead.

Why Shame Never Motivates

I don’t get angry often, but watching the Netflix documentary Fit for TV: The Reality of The Biggest Loser left me both furious and heartbroken. It revealed the brutal humiliation contestants endured: eight-hour workouts, dehydration, collapse, all packaged as entertainment. And worse? Many of us absorbed the message that humiliation equals transformation.

The reality is that shame doesn’t create change, it creates anxiety and self-defeat. Neuroscience shows that self-criticism activates your brain’s threat system and impairs clear thinking. On the flip side, self-compassion lights up the caregiving system, releases oxytocin, and keeps your problem-solving brain online. Decades of research from Carol Dweck’s growth mindset to BJ Fogg’s habit science prove that compassion fuels resilience, while shame shuts it down.

Three Strategies to Coach Yourself with Compassion

So how do we ditch the troll and step into a kinder, more effective way of motivating ourselves? Here are three simple but powerful strategies I use with my clients and in my own life:

That voice in your head speaks in absolutes: always, never, you’re a failure. Name it for what it is, a heckler not a coach. Try the best-friend test: would you ever say those words to your closest friend? If not, you know they don’t belong in your own head.

Kristin Neff’s research gives us a three-step tool: notice your suffering, remember you’re human, and offer yourself kindness. Then add an evidence check: what growth would your past self be proud of? Often your body already knows what you need, whether it is rest, water, fresh air, or connection.

Perfectionism isn’t about standards, it’s about fear. Start embracing “good enough.” Send the email that is 90% there. Do the workout that fits your energy today. Progress, not perfection, creates momentum and builds the life you actually want.

Three Key Takeaways

1️⃣ Shame doesn’t motivate, it paralyses your brain and keeps you stuck.
2️⃣ Self-compassion activates your brain’s growth system and fuels clarity, resilience, and real change.
3️⃣ You can fire your inner troll and coach yourself with kindness, starting today.

Join the Movement!

If you enjoyed this episode, you're going to love my newsletter! I dive deeper into these topics and share exclusive tools, guides, and behind-the-scenes insights that I don't share anywhere else. It's like getting your own coach in your inbox every week. Subscribe at https://go.unwritten.coach/newsletter  to join our community to get unstuck, grow and unleash your Unwritten Potential!